Is Wonderbly legit?
Yes. Wonderbly, a London publisher, has sold Lost My Name since 2013, and 91,773 Trustpilot reviewers rate it 4.5, “Excellent”, checked November 15, 2026. It says it has sold over 8 million copies of it. Penguin Random House announced it was buying Wonderbly on June 4, 2025. Wonderbly prints US orders in its US workshop and replied to all 282 recent US low-star reviews we read.
Whether it’s worth it starts with the delivered price. A US buyer wrote, 3 stars, August 15, 2026: “For a paperback book, I thought base prize of $35USD was high … Plus tax and $10 shipping made the total $50!”
Wonderbly and Paperlake compared
Prices in US dollars. Wonderbly’s checked November 15, 2026.
| Brand | Price | Delivery | What’s personalized | Preview before you pay | Made from a photo |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paperlake | $69 hardcover, $79 Keepsake, shipping included | Up to 3 business days to make, then up to 7 business days in the mail. Arrival date shown before you pay | The story, the people and pets in it, every picture | the whole story, the cover and the first two pages | ![]() |
| Wonderbly | Softcover $39.99, hardcover $49.99, layflat $69.99, plus shipping and tax | Printed in 2 to 4 business days, then standard, express “within 3-5 working days”, or express priority | First name, one of three preset characters with hair and skin tone, a dedication | all 22 pages | a preset character. You can add a photo on some titles |
| Paperlake | Wonderbly | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $69 hardcover, $79 Keepsake, shipping included | Softcover $39.99, hardcover $49.99, layflat $69.99, plus shipping and tax |
| Delivery | Up to 3 business days to make, then up to 7 business days in the mail. Arrival date shown before you pay | Printed in 2 to 4 business days, then standard, express “within 3-5 working days”, or express priority |
| What’s personalized | The story, the people and pets in it, every picture | First name, one of three preset characters with hair and skin tone, a dedication |
| Preview before you pay | the whole story, the cover and the first two pages | all 22 pages |
| Made from a photo | ![]() | a preset character. You can add a photo on some titles |
Wonderbly or a book made from their photo?
Choose Wonderbly if…
A publisher’s name you know
From $39.99, no photo needed
A long dedication, printed free
Choose Paperlake if…
A story written for them
Painted from the photos you send
Their family and pets in it
What is personalized in a Wonderbly book?
Wonderbly personalizes the first name, one of its preset characters and a dedication, and every child with that name gets the same story. Lost My Name offers “three little characters to choose from, for both boy and girl”, with hair and skin tone options, checked November 7, 2026. Newer titles add glasses and eye color. The free dedication runs to 400 characters and 10 lines, and you can upload a photo.
US buyers say the characters miss their child:
- August 31, 2026, 3 stars: “There is one option for most books for African Americans … only the darkest shade is available.”
- July 6, 2026, 2 stars: “on the books that only have 6 different children to choose from, 5 of them have straight hair, and the curly hair one was too dark for my daughter”
Others find the story thin:
- September 17, 2026, 3 stars: “The story line doesn’t really change across the books … about half the characters were reused or similar across the books.”
- September 30, 2026, 3 stars: “They are very cute books. Nothing overly special about him other than seeing your name.”
- A REVIEWS.io reviewer, quoted in Google’s summary for “wonderbly review”: “It’s a copy and paste book idea. Barely personalized”
With Paperlake, you tell us about the child: who they are, the people and pets around them, a real day you want kept. We write their story, and the pictures are painted from the photos you send. Three people come included and up to six fit, at $10 each from the fourth.

Can I see the book before I pay, and what if it’s wrong?
Yes, with both. Wonderbly previews all 22 pages of Lost My Name before you buy and gives you “a couple of hours” after ordering to make edits. After that, its terms say “we aren’t able to accept any returns or exchanges” and “once an order has been placed, we’re unable to cancel”. It makes faults right. We checked both on November 7, 2026.
Some US buyers’ books still came out wrong:
- October 25, 2026, 2 stars, a Christmas book: “When I was choosing, it looked different. I don’t believe the graphics look much like what I had chosen.”
- October 3, 2026, 3 stars, grandsons’ Christmas books: “I requested a special note to be put in one or both of the books, and it was not printed.”
- September 14, 2026, 1 star: “there is a half repeated page … I would like a refund”
With Paperlake, you read the whole story and see the cover and the first two pages before you pay. Change any line, and ask for another cover if it isn’t them. Not happy with it? Send us a photo and we’ll reprint it. No questions asked.
How much does a Wonderbly book cost with shipping?
On Wonderbly’s US site, checked November 15, 2026, Lost My Name is $39.99 in softcover, $49.99 in hardcover and $69.99 in layflat, plus shipping and sales tax. Wonderbly labels the hardcover “Most popular” and charges for extras:
- Cover color, three of the four: +$3.00
- Premium giftbox: +$6.99
- Deluxe Giftbox: +$12.99
- Giftwrap: +$4.99
Wonderbly shows the shipping cost “up front during checkout, after entering in your delivery address”, and has no free-shipping threshold. US buyers on the total:
- September 17, 2026, 3 stars: “It was almost $50USD after shipping for the one book.”
- October 11, 2026, 3 stars: “Shipping should be included considering how much the books cost.”
Paperlake costs more. Our hardcover is $69, about $19 above Wonderbly’s before its shipping and tax, but it includes shipping and we collect no sales tax. The extra buys a story written for one child, with pictures painted from the photos you send. The Keepsake, the book plus a 6-photo album and an online copy, is $79. A second copy is $29.
Will a Wonderbly book arrive by Christmas?
Yes, if you order a softcover by December 17 or 19, depending on your state. Wonderbly’s “Last order dates by US State (Softcover only)” are for standard shipping, and it publishes no Christmas date for the hardcover or layflat. We checked these on November 7, 2026:
- December 17: AL, AZ, AR, FL, IL, IN, IA, KS, KY, LA, ME, MN, MS, MT, NE, NV, NM, ND, OK, OR, SC, SD, TN, TX, VT, WA, WI, WY
- December 19: CA, CO, CT, DE, DC, GA, ID, MD, MA, MI, MO, NH, NJ, NY, NC, OH, PA, RI, UT, VA, WV
- Alaska and Hawaii: “See checkout”
- Priority express: December 21 for every state, on Wonderbly’s UK version of the page
Wonderbly’s Christmas FAQ puts printing at 1 to 3 days, against “2-4 business days” elsewhere on its site. Express goes by UPS, FedEx or DHL “within 3-5 working days” for most locations, and PO Boxes and APO/FPO addresses get standard only.
US buyers who paid for a date and missed it:
- January 15, 2026, 2 stars: “they said would be delivered December 21 in time for Christmas … December 24 came and received email saying December 30. Two little grandsons had to wait a week after Christmas to read their personalized How They Saved Christmas … Spent over $125 to be disappointed.”
- October 31, 2026, 1 star: “Paid extra for expedited shipping and the book was 3 days late”
- July 9, 2026, 1 star: “they didn’t send it express. They sent it regular ground shipping … I had no Father’s Day gift for my husband’s first Father’s Day”
Paperlake’s Christmas date is for a hardcover: order by Tuesday, December 8, 2026. We make each book in up to 3 business days and print it in the US, then it spends up to 7 business days in the mail. You see the arrival date before you pay.
What is the Lost My Name book?
Lost My Name is Wonderbly’s first book, and the child’s first name drives its story. It’s $39.99 in softcover, for ages 0 to 8, with 22 pages at A4 size. People look elsewhere when the child already has one, or when they want the child’s face and their own story. For more choices, see personalized children’s books compared.
What do Wonderbly’s US buyers complain about?
Late, lost or damaged mail leads, then thin or generic stories and refund trouble. On November 7, 2026 we read Wonderbly’s 500 most recent 1 to 3 star Trustpilot reviews from the last 12 months, capped at 200 one-star, 200 two-star and 100 three-star, so they are the newest low stars, not a census. US reviewers wrote 282, from December 8, 2025 to November 5, 2026: 99 one-star, 116 two-star, 67 three-star. We set aside 54 about the adult newspaper and birth-date books and sorted 228 by keyword, and one review can count in several themes. Read the counts against Wonderbly’s 4.5 from 91,773 reviews.
| Complaint | US reviews, of 228 | Percent | Where Paperlake differs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Late, lost or damaged in the mail | 73 | 32% | Arrival date shown before you pay, a hardcover Christmas date. No US delivery record yet |
| Story thin, generic or not as chosen | 36 | 16% | A story written for one child |
| Refund or replacement trouble | 35 | 15% | A reprint if you’re not happy |
| Price, shipping or add-ons | 34 | 15% | We cost more. Shipping included |
| Print or binding fault | 28 | 12% | No difference claimed |
| Customer service slow | 23 | 10% | No difference claimed |
| Character not like the child | 14 | 6% | Painted from the photos you send |
| Paid express, still late | 8 | 4% | As for late mail |
| Name, dedication or text wrong | 7 | 3% | Every line read before you pay |
US low stars peaked at 56 in June 2026, around Father’s Day, then ran 30 to 40 a month from July to October. The Christmas misses fall in December 2025 and January 2026, and 11 reviews name Christmas.
- September 22, 2026, 1 star: “I received the wrong book and when I asked for a replacement, I never received it.”
What Wonderbly does well
Wonderbly sells Mother’s Day, Father’s Day and sibling titles, needs no photo, and with BOGO50 a second book is half price. Its US five-star buyers include grandparents:
- November 5, 2026: “This year I got two for my youngest grandchildren one from each grandparent”
- October 31, 2026: “I love that I can send a message to him in the front of the book that he can read when he is older and still have when I am gone”
- November 5, 2026, a father-and-son book: “my husband sobbed while reading it … I also loved the storyline”
Where Wonderbly falls short
The child is a preset character, and every child with that name gets the same story. Shipping and tax come on top, the Christmas dates cover the softcover only, and you can’t return, exchange or cancel.
What Paperlake does differently
We write a story for one child, with their family and pets, and the pictures are painted from the photos you send. It’s $69 with shipping, and the hardcover Christmas date is Tuesday, December 8, 2026.
Where Paperlake falls short
We cost more, $69 against $49.99 for Wonderbly’s hardcover before its shipping and tax. We’re newer, with no US delivery record yet and nothing near its 91,773 reviews. We need photos of the child, and Wonderbly needs none.
Is Wonderbly worth it?
Wonderbly is worth it for a known publisher’s book at a lower price, if a softcover by December 17 or 19 suits your Christmas. If the book should belong to one child, choose Paperlake, and read every word before you pay.
Sources
- Wonderbly US, Lost My Name product page: formats, prices, extras, characters, dedication, 22-page preview. Prices checked November 15, 2026; the rest November 7, 2026.
- Wonderbly US, delivery and Christmas delivery pages: printing days, shipping methods, last order dates by state. Checked November 7, 2026.
- Wonderbly help center: edits after ordering, returns, cancellation, shipping cost at checkout. Checked November 7, 2026.
- Trustpilot, wonderbly.com: 4.5 from 91,773 reviews, read November 15, 2026, and the 500 most recent 1 to 3 star reviews from the last 12 months, read November 7, 2026.
- Wikipedia, Wonderbly: Penguin Random House acquisition announced June 4, 2025. Read November 7, 2026.
- Google results for “wonderbly review”, quoting a REVIEWS.io review. Read November 7, 2026.
- Reddit, r/BabyBumpsCanada, “Has anyone purchased from Wonderbly?”, May 2022, comments to 2024.

Paperlake publishes this comparison and is one of the two brands in it. We read every Wonderbly fact here on November 7, 2026, except its prices (November 15, 2026) and Trustpilot count (November 15, 2026), and suggest you read independent reviews too.
Their own story, from your photos
a preset character. You can add a photo on some titles